Wednesday, July 25, 2012

WebDriver: Y U NO HAVE HTTP Status Codes?!

There's a long-standing issue in the Selenium issue tracker dealing with the fact that the WebDriver API does not expose HTTP status codes to the user. For those of you who like to keep score at home, it's issue #141 in the tracker. The issue was opened in February, 2009, and was closed as "Won't Fix" in December of that year. Despite the finality of many project contributors and the main project architect saying that this feature will not be made available, it has continued to garner comments, many vehement, for reconsideration. I'm going to try to spend a little bit making what I hope is a reasoned, rational argument why this decision was made, and why the feature isn't needed in the project.

How Did We Get Here?

What follows is an oversimplified brief recap of some history. In the beginning was Selenium RC, which was an API that grew organically during its existence, with no rhyme or reason for how methods were tacked onto its single object. Over time, it became a brilliant example of the God object anti-pattern, violating all kinds of object-oriented programming principles. One of the more obscure methods engendered by the organic growth of the project was called captureNetworkTraffic(). This method purported to capture all of the network traffic between the browser and the site being automated, and was made possible because in some browser configurations, Selenium acted as a proxy between the browser and the site being automated, thus all browser traffic passed through Selenium, and could be captured or manipulated.

And so it came to pass that Selenium RC was found wanting, and lo, there was much weeping and wailing and gnashing of teeth in the browser automation community. And thus it was that the WebDriver project was born, and eventually merged into the Selenium project to become Selenium WebDriver. WebDriver was a completely different approach to browser automation, preferring to act more like a user, which solved the fundamental problems inherent in the Selenium RC approach. However, since much of the actual driving of the browser would now be done external to the browser itself, and with no proxy in between the browser and the site being automated, it made creating a method similar to captureNetworkTraffic() difficult at best, and impossible at worst. 

Where Are We Now?

This brings us to the current state of affairs, with HTTP status codes being unavailable in the WebDriver API. An architectural decision was made during the creation and development of the WebDriver API that this feature would not be implemented, and that it would be declared "out of scope" for Selenium WebDriver. This has caused some consternation among users, especially since the issue has been closed, and it's been said that the feature won't be implemented, and been said so in extremely plain, even blunt, terms. There are some valid technical reasons why this decision was made. Here are just a few of them:
  • What about redirects? Do you just return the last code after the redirect, or the code that indicates a redirect? What do you say to those who disagree with your answer to that question?
  • Some browsers make it impossible to get the status code. Do you really want an API that works on some browsers, but not others?
  • WebDriver is concerned with driving the browser, not necessarily just web application testing. Does returning HTTP status codes really fit this mission?
  • WebDriver is concerned with driving the browser as a user would. Does a browser show HTTP status codes to the user, or just rendered pages?

Nevertheless, that hasn't stopped people from arguing that it should be included. Let's take a few minutes to examine some of those arguments, and then we'll take a look at what options there are for solving this issue.

"HTTP status codes are an important part of website testing."

Yes, I can see the argument that HTTP status codes could be an important part of testing your website. However, while web application testing is an important use case of the Selenium project, it's far from the only one. A frequent response to this is, "But your own web pages and literature say it's for web application testing!" That's a fair critique about documentation and public perception of the project, but that's really a separate discussion. HTTP status codes are not a required part of automating the browser.

"I don't care that it doesn't work on all browsers, I need those status codes."

One of the major advantages of the WebDriver API over what has come before is its elegance and purity. Implementing a solution that works in only some browsers is vastly inferior to one that works for all browsers, especially when the solution isn't in the core competency of the library. There are solutions that do work for all browsers without polluting the API, albeit they require integration with other tools that <gasp> are not Selenium. Tacking on this feature for some browsers in a suboptimal way that might miss important edge cases because it's not a core competency is akin to driving a wood screw into a board with a hammer because that's the only tool you have. Yes, it'll work, but it's not going to be pretty, and is likely to fail you somewhere down the line.

"Other parts of the WebDriver API let you do things a user can't do, why not expose status codes?"

Proponents of this argument usually cite manipulation of cookies, or finding of elements by anything other than visual inspection, or viewing a page's HTML source, or any number of other items. All of those items are germane to interacting with the page itself, with what is displayed. The HTTP status code is not directly concerned with what is displayed on the page.

"But so many people want the feature, you should really add it."

Ah, yes, the old, "But I want a pony," argument. Or it's corollary, "20 million New Kids On The Block fans can't be wrong!" This argument is occasionally followed by a sometimes hostile, "Well, your lack of this feature makes your library completely useless to me," or even, "You'd better add it or else I'll stop using it!" This latter response is the equivalent of, "I'm going to hold my breath until you give me exactly what I want!" Just because something's popular doesn't make it a good idea.

Where Do We Go From Here?

Just as proponents of wanting to see HTTP status codes in the WebDriver API are convinced that the arguments against including it don't hold water, the members of the project team are equally convinced that adding it is a bad idea. So if you feel like you absolutely need to have them, what can you do? Well, you have a couple of options.

Remember how I said earlier that Selenium RC was able to give you this information because it acted as a proxy? You can recreate that exact same environment with WebDriver! Of course, you have to use a dedicated proxy to do it, but guess what? There are lots of software proxies around that make this really easy. Additionally, you're using the proxy to capture the traffic, not something half-baked that's been shoehorned into the WebDriver API, which is a little thing I like to call using the right tool for the job. As an example, the BrowserMob proxy is one that's being used successfully by lots of people. It's open-source, and it's written in Java, so if you're using Java, you can even control it directly from your existing code. If you're not using Java, fear not, as there are wrapper libraries written for many different languages, including Python, .NET, Ruby, and PHP, to name a few. The WebDriver library even allows you to set the browser you're automating to use the proxy.

"But I don't want to use a proxy! I only want to have to manage Selenium as a dependency," I hear you say. I've got a little secret for you: WebDriver is Open Source Software. It's even very liberally licensed. If you don't like a decision made by the project team, fork it, create a patch, and share with the world. I personally love innovation in the Open Source world. Don't tell me how you want to see it done, show me, with working code. Unless you can demonstrate your solution working for all browsers though, I'll probably use a proxy if I need this functionality, and that's my choice.  
   

128 comments:

  1. The problem with BrowserMob is that it's still in beta phase and it's not very stable. Although I've used it successfully in many project it's been always causing some problems sometimes to the extent that I had to abandon it. Alternatively I use Firefox+Firebug+NetExport but this solution is slow and has it's drawbacks too. If anyone knows about a stable proxy I could use with Java I would appreciate if they share their knowledge.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for the explanation Jim. You motivated me to write a blog with some alternatives and workarounds for those of use who need this feature:

      http://www.ninthavenue.com.au/how-to-get-the-http-status-code-in-selenium-webdriver

      Delete
  2. Not exposing HTTP Status codes was the single most important reason I stopped using Selenium WebDriver. It's just a way too important detail about HTTP to leave out of an HTTP testing framework.

    The only argument you make that holds water (imho) is that introducing HTTP status codes won't make it coherent across all implementations. The solution to this is to throw exception in browsers that don't expose it. People are used to special-case their for different browsers already, so this wouldn't cause much confusion (if the exception thrown has an intuitive message, at least).

    So, I didn't understand this decision before reading this blog post and still don't.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Just out of curiosity, what did you decide to use instead?

      I'll point out that WebDriver is most emphatically *not* an "HTTP testing framework," except in the sense that it drives a browser, which uses HTTP to communicate with a server.

      Once again, there are options, the most extreme of which is to implement it, and show me how it's done. Less extreme is to use the right tool for capturing that information, a proxy.

      Rather than continue to shout at the proverbial rain about what idiots the developers are for making poor decisions, I invite you to be the agent of the change you want to see.

      Delete
    2. Not sure why you characterize @asbjornu's arguments as "continuing to shout at the proverbial rain." That implies that WebDriver cannot possibly change - which is untrue.

      Would you characterize Sun Suu Kyi's decades of resistance to the Myan Mar regime in the same way? Maybe WebDriver *won't* change, but that doesn't per se imply that Selenium's users who see the change in direction as a serious mistake should stop replying to posts that defend the decision.

      Delete
    3. Nice strawman you've created there. There's a fundamental difference between political regimes and a discussion about API decisions in an open-source project. Furthermore, I resent the comparison.

      I'd never suggest that anyone should stop making the case for an opinion they hold. Having said that, the important thing to take away from my comments are that if it's that all-fired important to someone, there are other courses of action than just "replying to posts that defend the decision." Create the change. Write the code. Show me a patch that implements the way you want it to work.

      I suspect I know what many people's response to the "do it yourself" attitude may be, but I'll give my audience the benefit of the doubt and refrain from attempting a preemptive response.

      Delete
    4. Sorry the comparison to Myan Mar got in your way ... that was not the point of the comparison. The point (I could have been more explicit but I thought it was clear) was your apparent characterization of continued opposition as pointless and foolish.

      I agree with the take-away you explained in this last comment: those who disagree are encouraged not only to express their disagreement but also to help create the change. But what you said before was not "Rather than *just* continue... I *also* invite you to", but "Rather than continue ... I invite you to". So yes, you did appear to be suggesting that he stop making the case for the opinion he holds. I'm glad to hear that is not the case.

      Delete
    5. Likewise, I thought my statement was clear as well, that I'm not opposed to a thoughtful, respectful discussion of differing opinion, but that actions are even better. I apologize for the lack of clarity.

      Delete
    6. While I agree with you, Jim, in that the most constructive thing to do would be to provide a patch or something similar to show how it could be done, I'm not a Java developer, so that would require a bit more investment on my part than having what this feature is worth to me.

      Having said that, I still think a good way to implement it is to throw exceptions in the one(?) browser where it's not available, and return the status code in the others. Redirects should be handled like they are now; they can be followed automatically (in which case you should return the status code of the final page) or they can be followed manually (in which case you should return the HTTP redirect status code of the one or many redirecting pages in-between).

      But as I wrote, I've moved on. I and the company I work for am now using HtmlUnit (or rather, NHtmlUnit) directly, since it was headless testing we were after all along. The JavaScript support is so-so, but it's better than nothing and helps us tremendously in keeping a solid harness around our web applications.

      Delete
    7. If "headless testing" is what you were really after, then it sounds like you made the right decision. As much as I like the project and am invested in it, WebDriver isn't the right tool for every job. NHtmlUnit is an interesting choice.

      There are just a couple of misconceptions that I want to correct. Given your stated goals, you were probably more interested in the HtmlUnitDriver than any other implementation, but I don't want anyone to come away from this discussion with the idea that you *must* be a Java developer to make meaningful contributions to WebDriver. If you're changing something in the WebDriver API, submitting that change in any language binding would be fine. For the implementation side on a specific browser, that language will change depending on the driver implementation (C++ for Chrome and IE, mostly JavaScript for Firefox and Safari, Objective-C for iPhone, and so on).

      Yes, that may be a huge investment for someone who's not natively a developer in those languages, and that's a perfectly fair assessment. Nevertheless, that's the tradeoff one always faces when using open-source software, is my pain at not having a feature greater than the effort it would require for me to build it myself. This is especially true when the project is produced entirely by unpaid volunteers, as WebDriver is.

      Finally, it isn't just one browser that makes it impossible to get the HTTP status code, there are at least three that I know of. IE, Safari desktop and mobile Safari (iPhone) are all in that boat. Android may or may not be, I honestly don't know.

      Delete
    8. Jim,

      An old thread I know, but new to me.

      I want to "create robust, browser-based regression automation" for my project, written in python. Selenium seems like the perfect tool for me, in fact I grabbed the requirements text from http://docs.seleniumhq.org/, as they matched my needs exactly.

      After getting a few simple test cases going, I wanted to expand automation suite to include checks for various HTTP status codes. Imagine my surprise to see they are not available.

      In the perhaps naive attempt to have your team reconsider this early design decision, allow me to respond to your stated rational

      - It was an early design decision not to return HTTP status codes. This one should be easy; lots of decisions made early in a project get reconsideration based on user feedback, right?

      - What about redirects? redirects can be handled in a few ways, but if you want to start with returning the last status code, that would likely handle a large percentage of the test needs, and that approach seems to be consistent with the concept of matching the user experience with the tool.

      - Some browsers make it impossible to get the status. OK, I’m sure a lot of your users can live with that. >50% is a lot better than 0% coverage of this feature.

      - Webdriver does more than support testing. I get it, but you promote it as a test tool, so I assume you want it to be a great test tool. Why would you limit its usability for this case because there are other use cases?

      - Webdriver drives the browser like a user. Users can see the HTTP status codes in most modern browsers.

      Anyway, it might be informative if you take a poll on the topic. It is surprising to see such resistance to a popular idea with some technical merit.

      Delete
  3. Yes, I can see the argument that HTTP status codes could be an important part of testing your website.

    It's encouraging to see that you are listening to these important points in favor of exposing HTTP status codes.

    while web application testing is an important use case of the Selenium project, it's far from the only one

    That's a bit like saying that going forward is an important use case for a car. The Seleniumhq web site says it is the *primary* use case: "Primarily it is for automating web applications for testing purposes." And it's very difficult to reconcile this with your conclusion that "the feature isn't needed in the project".

    That's a fair critique about documentation and public perception of the project, but that's really a separate discussion.

    You can try to separate it, but it still needs to be addressed, because this whole issue turns on the question (it didn't use to be a question at all) of whether Selenium is for testing web applications. Until the conflict between public promises of web application testing, and statements that WebDriver is only for browser automation, are addressed, you will continue to have users who feel like they've been "baited and switched."

    HTTP status codes are not a required part of automating the browser.

    This just begs the above question.

    I hear you acknowledging that the feature is important, but that it would be very difficult to implement in a way that works across all browsers. That's a fair answer. Asking others to help/implement the feature is a fair answer, if the project committers would accept contributions. What's not fair is claiming that web application testing features are not needed in Selenium/WebDriver, despite years of marketing Selenium as a web application testing tool.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "if the project committers would accept contributions" should read "if the project committers would accept such contributions"

      Delete
    2. I believe the issue of "whether Selenium is for testing web applications" *is* a separate discussion. Clearly you believe it to be the central issue. It's not one I'm prepared to discuss or debate.

      With respect to the specific issue of HTTP status codes, to date, I've not seen any submissions or contributions from anyone attempting to solve the problem. If you have, and if you feel they've been rejected out of hand without consideration, please point me to the artifacts of that submission.

      Delete
  4. This is probably too late for anyone to read.. but just in case.. I am using Webdriver and a site I test, upon login, redirects me to another page. The response on login is 302. When I do this manually the site works fine. When I record a script using Selenium IDE and play it back, it works fine (uses clickAndWait). For some reason, despite putting wait code in my java webdriver code, the redirect never occurs upon login and the main login screen shows up again. It's as if the browser that is being driven just doesn't issue the redirect for some reason. I've no idea why this is. I would love to have access to the status code and if it's a 302, grab the location and use webdriver to navigate to that location, but obviously that's impossible. I'd be fine without the codes if the webdriver driven browser would just redirect while my code "waits" for an element to show up.

    If any of you know why this happens.. why selenium ide works, manual works, but webdriver prevents the browser from redirecting.. I'd appreciate it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. First, thanks for taking the time to post a comment. Second, this really isn't the best place to get direct support for an issue like this; one of the user-facing mailing lists like selenium-users (https://groups.google.com/forum/?fromgroups#!forum/selenium-users) or the webdriver list (https://groups.google.com/forum/?fromgroups#!forum/webdriver) would be.

      As for your exact question, redirects via 302 HTTP status codes are not globally broken for every page everywhere. There is an explicit test for this in the WebDriver tests, and it passes on all browsers we test against (http://ci.seleniumhq.org:8080/).

      Without seeing the exact page you're testing against, I could only hazard a wild guess as to the cause. I'd certainly be suspicious of JavaScript running on the login page that doesn't fully initialize the user name and password, so the user name and password you're typing into the login page aren't being sent when the button is clicked.

      Delete
    2. Hey Jim.. wow.. thought maybe this would never be read. Thank you.

      The site happens to have an option when you register to redirect you to a search page when you log in. Being a JEE web app developer, I am surprised it just doesn't respond with the page directly, but instead this site sends a redirect (302) to the browser so that it can then redirect to the specific search page rather than the default internal home page.

      For the record, I've posted on a few forums, selenium and otherwise, and so far no help or ideas.

      Can you elaborate on how to use Webdriver to test for this?

      Like I said, it's strange to me that Webdriver stops the web browser from redirecting.. if that is what is going on. I would have thought the wait code snippet (or a Thread.sleep()) would work, allowing the browser being driving to carry out the redirect. Looking at web developer I can only see that the POST goes to the server with a 302 response. When I manually do this, the 302 comes back, then a GET request is issued and the search page is returned. When I do this with Webdriver, the 302 is returned but many more GET requests (for js, images, etc) are issued. Finally a last GET to another site is issued.

      I don't know..it's an odd issue..but one I fixed by simply switching back to the default home page, and now I am off to control the rest of the site. It may be that this particular web site is written badly or doing something it shouldn't and is out of the scope of Webdriver to respond properly to. Still, can't help wonder why only when driven by webdriver does it do this, but the IDE and manually doing so do not cause this to happen.

      Thanks.

      Delete
  5. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi,
    Well explained about Rantings of a Selenium Contributor. can you explain about What is the difference between Selenium core extensions and Selenium IDE extensions?
    Thanks,
    David,
    Selenium Developer

    ReplyDelete
  7. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  8. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  9. While I appreciate that getting the response codes is not always possible, the argument that Selenium mimics a real browser user doesn't hold much water.

    Why? Because a computer program is not a person.

    When I browse to my favourite site, to read the news or to watch a funny cat video, I do so with the specific purpose of getting information, or entertainment, or whatever. A computer program going to the same site does so for very different reasons: either to test the site, or to scrape information from it. A computer program doesn't care about what happened in the world, or cat antics.

    A computer program needs to get information from the responses to the requests it makes. And some of the most valuable sources of information.

    It's not a problem that not all browsers offer this information. In fact, it's totally irrelevant. If I write a computer program that needs this information, then it's up to me to choose a browser that does. It's not up to Selenium to decide that I can't have this information, because some browsers that I don't care about don't offer it.

    ReplyDelete
  10. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  11. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  12. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  13. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  14. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  15. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  16. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  17. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  18. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I have read your blog completely. It is very impressive one for all the viewers. Thanks for sharing this blog.

    selenium training in chennai

    ReplyDelete
  20. Thanks for sharing this blog. This very important and informative blog Learned a lot of new things from your post! Good creation and HATS OFF to the creativity of your mind.
    Very interesting and useful blog!
    best wireless bluetooth headphones
    best power bank for mobile
    dual sim smartphone
    keypad mobiles with wifi and whatsapp
    best smartphone accessories
    basic mobile phones dual sim low price
    Best Mouse under 300
    best wired Mouse under 500
    full hd computer monitor

    ReplyDelete
  21. Great Article… I love to read your articles because your writing style is too good, its is very very helpful for all of us and I never get bored while reading your article because, they are becomes a more and more interesting from the starting lines until the end.
    Data science training in velachery
    Data science training in kalyan nagar
    Data Science training in OMR
    Data Science training in anna nagar
    Data Science training in chennai
    Data Science training in marathahalli
    Data Science training in BTM layout
    Data Science training in rajaji nagar

    ReplyDelete
  22. I found your blog while searching for the updates, I am happy to be here. Very useful content and also easily understandable providing.. Believe me I did wrote an post about tutorials for beginners with reference of your blog. 

    Devops training in velachry
    Devops training in OMR
    Deops training in annanagar
    Devops training in chennai
    Devops training in marathahalli
    Devops training in rajajinagar
    Devops training in BTM Layout

    ReplyDelete
  23. Thanks for sharing this blog. This very important and informative blog Learned a lot of new things from your post! Good creation and HATS OFF to the creativity of your mind.
    Very interesting and useful blog!
    simultaneous interpretation booth

    silent disco headphones

    silent disco headphones
    silent disco headphones
    simultaneous interpretation equipment

    simultaneous interpretation equipment

    bosch simultaneous interpretation system

    ReplyDelete
  24. Thanks for the informative article. This is one of the best resources I have found in quite some time. Nicely written and great info. I really cannot thank you enough for sharing.
    Blueprism training in Chennai

    Blueprism training in Bangalore

    Blueprism training in Pune

    Blueprism training in tambaram

    Blueprism training in annanagar

    Blueprism training in velachery

    Blueprism training in marathahalli

    ReplyDelete

  25. It’s great to come across a blog every once in a while that isn’t the same out of date rehashed material. Fantastic read.

    Digital Marketing Training in Mumbai

    Six Sigma Training in Dubai

    Six Sigma Abu Dhabi

    ReplyDelete
  26. This is most informative and also this post most user friendly and super navigation to all posts... Thank you so much for giving this information to me.. 


    java training in chennai | java training in bangalore

    java online training | java training in pune

    selenium training in chennai

    selenium training in bangalore

    ReplyDelete
  27. Your good knowledge and kindness in playing with all the pieces were very useful. I don’t know what I would have done if I had not encountered such a step like this.


    Devops Training in pune

    Devops Training in Chennai

    Devops Training in Bangalore

    AWS Training in chennai

    AWS Training in bangalore

    ReplyDelete
  28. I would like to thank you for your nicely written post, its informative and your writing style encouraged me to read it till end. Thanks

    angularjs-Training in annanagar

    angularjs Training in chennai

    angularjs Training in chennai

    angularjs Training in bangalore

    ReplyDelete
  29. Webtrackker Technology is IT Company and also providing the Solidwork
    training in Noida at running project by the real time working trainers.
    If you are looking for the Best Solidwork training institute in Noida
    then you can contact to webtrackker technology.
    Webtrackker Technology
    C- 67, Sector- 63 (Noida)
    Phone: 0120-4330760, 8802820025
    8802820025
    Solidwork training institute in Noida

    ReplyDelete
  30. myTectra placement Portal is a Web based portal brings Potentials Employers and myTectra Candidates on a common platform for placement assistance.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Really great post, Thank you for sharing This knowledge.Excellently written article, if only all bloggers offered the same level of content as you, the internet would be a much better place. Please keep it up!
    python online training
    python training in chennai

    ReplyDelete
  32. Thanks for the informative article. This is one of the best resources I have found in quite some time. Nicely written and great info. I really cannot thank you enough for sharing.angularjs Training in bangalore

    angularjs Training in btm

    angularjs Training in electronic-city

    angularjs Training in online

    angularjs Training in marathahalli

    ReplyDelete
  33. After reading your post I understood that last week was with full of surprises and happiness for you. Congratz! Even though the website is work related, you can update small events in your life and share your happiness with us too.
    java training in tambaram | java training in velachery

    java training in omr | oracle training in chennai

    ReplyDelete

  34. Nice blog..! I really loved reading through this article. Thanks for sharing such a amazing post with us and keep blogging...


    Best Data Science online training in Hyderabad

    Data Science training in Hyderabad

    Data Science online training in Hyderabad

    ReplyDelete
  35. Very nice post here and thanks for it .I always like and such a super contents of these post.Excellent and very cool idea and great content of different kinds of the valuable information's.
    Good discussion. Thank you.
    Anexas
    Six Sigma Training in Abu Dhabi
    Six Sigma Training in Dammam
    Six Sigma Training in Riyadh

    ReplyDelete
  36. Thanks you for sharing this unique useful information content with us. Really awesome work. keep on blogging
    python training in OMR
    python training in tambaram
    python training in annanagar

    ReplyDelete
  37. Really very nice blog information for this one and more technical skills are improve,i like that kind of post.
    Devops Training in pune

    ReplyDelete
  38. This is a good post. This post give truly quality information. I’m definitely going to look into it. Really very useful tips are provided here. thank you so much. Keep up the good works.
    SEO Training in Chennai
    SEO training course
    Best SEO training in chennai
    SEO Training Center in Chennai
    SEO Training near me

    ReplyDelete
  39. We are Offerining DevOps Training in Bangalore,Chennai, Pune using Class Room. myTectra offers Live Online DevOps Training Globally

    ReplyDelete
  40. Good job in presenting the correct content with the clear explanation. The content looks real with valid information. Good Work

    DevOps is currently a popular model currently organizations all over the world moving towards to it. Your post gave a clear idea about knowing the DevOps model and its importance.

    Good to learn about DevOps at this time.

    devops training in chennai | devops training in chennai with placement | devops training in chennai omr | devops training in velachery | devops training in chennai tambaram | devops institutes in chennai | devops certification in chennai

    ReplyDelete
  41. Excellent tutorial buddy. Directly I saw your blog and way of teaching was perfect, Waiting for your next tutorial.
    best rpa training institute in chennai | rpa training in velachery | rpa training in chennai omr

    ReplyDelete
  42. Wow it is really wonderful and awesome thus it is very much useful for me to understand many concepts and helped me a lot. it is really explainable very well and i got more information from your blog.

    rpa training in velachery| rpa training in tambaram |rpa training in sholinganallur | rpa training in annanagar| rpa training in kalyannagar

    ReplyDelete
  43. Your way of approach on this increase the curosity for this topic. Requesting you to please sharing such type of information on Blueprism too beacuse many of people also searching such a great information on Blueprism too.
    Thanks and Regards,
    Blue prism training in chennai
    Best Blue prism training in chennai
    Blue prism training cost in chennai

    ReplyDelete
  44. Awwsome informative blog ,Very good information thanks for sharing such wonderful blog with us ,after long time came across such knowlegeble blog. keep sharing such informative blog with us. Aviation Courses in Chennai | Best Aviation Academy in Chennai
    Aviation Academy in Chennai | Aviation Training in Chennai | Aviation Institute in Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  45. Thank you sharing this kind of noteworthy information. Nice Post.

    smarthrsolution
    Guest posting sites

    ReplyDelete
  46. Thanks for posting such a great article.you done a great job selenium Online Training Bangalore

    ReplyDelete
  47. Hi,
    I must appreciate you for providing such a valuable content for us. This is one amazing piece of article. Helped a lot in increasing my knowledge.
    Web Designing Course in chennai
    Java Training in Chennai
    website design training
    Web Designing Institute in Chennai
    Java course in Chennai
    Java Training Institute in Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  48. This information is impressive. I am inspired with your post writing style & how continuously you describe this topic. Eagerly waiting for your new blog keep doing more.
    Android Training in Bangalore
    Android Course in Bangalore
    big data coaching in bangalore
    hadoop certification courses in bangalore
    hadoop training centers in bangalore

    ReplyDelete
  49. Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting?I have read a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style. Thanks a million and please keep up the effective work. R Programming institutes in Chennai | R Programming Training in Chennai | R Programming Course Fees

    ReplyDelete
  50. Brilliant ideas that you have share with us.It is really help me lot and i hope it will help others also.update more different ideas with us.
    python training institutes in bangalore
    python institutes in bangalore
    Python Courses in T nagar
    Python Training Institutes in T nagar

    ReplyDelete
  51. Awwsome informative blog ,Very good information thanks for sharing such wonderful blog with us ,after long time came across such knowlegeble blog. keep sharing such informative blog with us. Aviation Courses in Chennai | Best Aviation Academy in Chennai | Aviation Academy in Chennai | Aviation Training in Chennai | Aviation Institute in Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  52. Awwsome informative blog ,Very good information thanks for sharing such wonderful blog with us ,after long time came across such knowlegeble blog. keep sharing such informative blog with us. Aviation Courses in Chennai | Best Aviation Academy in Chennai | Aviation Academy in Chennai | Aviation Training in Chennai | Aviation Institute in Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  53. your blog informations are really creative and It contains full of new innovative ideas.thank you for sharing with us.please update more data.
    Salesforce Training in chennai
    Salesforce Training in Anna Nagar
    Salesforce Training Institutes in Vadapalani
    Salesforce Training in T nagar

    ReplyDelete
  54. The blog which you are shared is very much helpful for us to knew about the web designing. thanks for your information.
    Web Designing Institute
    Best Web Design Courses
    Web Design Training Courses
    Learn Website Design
    Best Way to Learn Web Design

    ReplyDelete
  55. Thanks for your sharing such a useful information. this was really helpful to me.

    payrollmanagementservice
    Article submission sites

    ReplyDelete
  56. Thanks for providing the information . The articles in your blog helped me a lot for improving the knowledge on the subject. Also check my small collection on this at selenium Online Training Hyderabad blog

    ReplyDelete
  57. Thanks for your sharing such a useful information. this was really helpful to me

    Article submission sites
    Guest posting sites

    ReplyDelete
  58. Outstanding blog thanks for sharing such wonderful blog with us ,after long time came across such knowlegeble blog. keep sharing such informative blog with us. Machine learning training in chennai | machine learning course fees in chennai

    ReplyDelete
  59. Great post! I am actually getting ready to across this information, It's very helpful for this blog.Also great with all of the valuable information you have Keep up the good work you are doing well.Trending Software Technologies in 2018 | Hadoop Training in Chennai | big data Hadoop training and certification in Chennai | Roles and reponsibilities of hadoop developer |

    ReplyDelete
  60. Greetings. I know this is somewhat off-topic, but I was wondering if you knew where I could get a captcha plugin for my comment form? I’m using the same blog platform like yours, and I’m having difficulty finding one? Thanks a lot.

    AWS Interview Questions And Answers

    AWS Tutorial |Learn Amazon Web Services Tutorials |AWS Tutorial For Beginners


    AWS Online Training | Online AWS Certification Course - Gangboard

    AWS Training in Toronto| Amazon Web Services Training in Toronto, Canada

    ReplyDelete
  61. Hmm, it seems like your site ate my first comment (it was extremely long) so I guess I’ll just sum it up what I had written and say
    nebosh course in chennai

    ReplyDelete
  62. This post is much helpful for us. This is really very massive value to all the readers and it will be the only reason for the post to get popular with great authority.
    Java J2ee Training in Chennai
    German Training Institute in Chennai
    german language coaching centres in chennai
    Java Coaching Center in Chennai
    Best Java Training in Chennai
    German Training Centers in Chennai


    ReplyDelete
  63. Brilliant ideas that you have share with us.It is really help me lot and i hope it will help others also.update more different ideas with us.
    best android training in bangalore
    Android Training in Anna Nagar
    Android Training in chennai
    Android Training in OMR

    ReplyDelete
  64. Your post is really awesome. Your blog is really helpful for me to develop my skills in a right way. Thanks for sharing this unique information with us.
    - Learn Digital Academy

    ReplyDelete
  65. Amazing blog you have given and you made a great work.surely i would look into this insight and i hope it will help me to clear my points.please share more information's.
    AngularJS Training in Amjikarai
    AngularJS courses in Anna Nagar
    Angularjs course in Bangalore
    Angularjs Training institute in Bangalore

    ReplyDelete
  66. nice blog check out https://www.ayevainstitute.com/

    ReplyDelete
  67. This post is much helpful for us. This is really very massive value to all the readers and it will be the only reason for the post to get popular with great authority.
    Selenium Training
    Selenium Course in Chennai
    Selenium Training Institute in Chennai
    Best Software Testing Training Institute in Chennai
    Testing training
    Software testing training institutes

    ReplyDelete
  68. This information is really awesome thanks for sharing most valuable information.
    RPA Blue Prism Online Training

    ReplyDelete



  69. Such a wonderful article on AWS. I think its the best information on AWS on internet today. Its always helpful when you are searching information on such an important topic like AWS and you found such a wonderful article on AWS with full information.Requesting you to keep posting such a wonderful article on other topics too.
    Thanks and regards,
    AWS training in chennai
    aws course in chennai what is the qualification
    aws authorized training partner in chennai
    aws certification exam centers in chennai
    aws course fees details
    aws training in Omr

    ReplyDelete
  70. Good job in presenting the correct content with the clear explanation. The content looks real with valid information. Good Work

    DevOps is currently a popular model currently organizations all over the world moving towards to it. Your post gave a clear idea about knowing the DevOps model and its importance.

    Good to learn about DevOps at this time.


    devops training in chennai | devops training in chennai with placement | devops training in chennai omr | devops training in velachery | devops training in chennai tambaram | devops institutes in chennai | devops certification in chennai | trending technologies list 2018

    ReplyDelete
  71. Very nice post here thanks for it .I always like and such a super contents of these post.Excellent and very cool idea and great content of different kinds of the valuable information's.
    Check out : machine learning Course in chennai

    machine learning with python course in Chennai

    ReplyDelete
  72. Thank you so much for your information,its very useful and helful to me.Keep updating and sharing. Thank you.
    RPA training in chennai | UiPath training in chennai

    ReplyDelete